Consumers Energy – April 2014

SupplierPlanRate per McfSavings
Consumers Energymonth to month$4.747N/A
Ardent Natural GasvariableCallCall
Ardent Natural GasMarch 2015 fixed$5.490-16%
Bishop Energy12 month variable$5.370-13%
Border EnergyOct. 2013 - Apr. 2014 fixed$4.6991%
Constellation Energymonth to month$7.990-68%
Constellation Energy12 month fixed$5.890-24%
Dillon Energy Servicesmonth to month$4.7201%
Dillon Energy Services12 month fixed$5.210-10%
Dillon Energy Services24 month fixed$5.160-9%
Direct Energy24 month fixed$5.690-20%
Glacial EnergyCallCallCall
Grand Rapids Energymonth to month$5.390-14%
Grand Rapids Energy6 month fixed$5.190-9%
Grand Rapids Energy12 month fixed$5.990-26%
IGS EnergyMar. 2015 fixed$5.790-22%
IGS EnergyMar. 2017 fixed$5.790-22%
Integrys Energy12 month variable$6.263-32%
Just Energy12 month fixed$6.790-43%
Just Energy36 month fixed$6.790-43%
Just Energy60 month fixed$6.790-43%
Just Energy60 month variable$4.7001%
Lakeshore EnergyApril 2015 variableCallCall
Lakeshore EnergyMarch 2015 fixed$5.550-17%
MIG&ECallCallCall
Michigan Natural GasOct. 2015 variableCallCall
My Choice Energymonth to monthCallCall
My Choice EnergyMarch 31, 2015 fixed$5.890-24%
My Choice EnergyMarch 31, 2016 fixed$5.550-17%
Santanna Energymonth to month$6.390-35%
Santanna Energy12 month fixed$6.740-42%
Smart One EnergyCallCallCall
Spark Energy12 month fixed$5.990-26%
Spark Energy24 month fixed$5.990-26%
Volunteer EnergyCallCallCall
XOOM Energymonth to month (promo)$4.995-5%
XOOM Energy6 month fixed$6.177-30%
XOOM Energy12 month fixed$6.490-37%
XOOM Energy24 month fixed$6.490-37%

DTE/MichCon – April 2014

SupplierPlanRate per CcfSavings
DTE/MichConmonth to month$0.4560N/A
Ardent Natural GasCallCallCall
Bishop Energy12 month variable$0.8580-88%
Border EnergyOct. 2013 - Apr. 2014 fixed$0.4699-3%
Constellation Energymonth to month$0.8290-82%
Constellation Energy12 month fixed$0.5890-29%
Dillon Energy Servicesmonth to month$0.4720-4%
Direct Energy24 month fixed$0.5690-25%
Glacial Energy12 month fixed$0.5718-25%
Grand Rapids Energymonth to month$0.5390-18%
Grand Rapids Energy6 month fixed$0.5190-14%
Grand Rapids Energy12 month fixed$0.5190-14%
IGS EnergyMar. 2015 fixed$0.5790-27%
IGS EnergyMar. 2017 fixed$0.5790-27%
Integrys Energy12 month variable$0.6263-37%
Just Energy12 month fixed$0.6800-49%
Just Energy36 month fixed$0.6800-49%
Just Energy60 month fixed$0.6800-49%
Just Energy60 month variable$0.4693-3%
Lakeshore EnergyMarch 2015 variableCallCall
Lakeshore EnergyMarch 2015 fixed$0.5550-22%
MIG&ECallCallCall
Michigan Natural GasCallCallCall
My Choice Energymonth to monthCallCall
My Choice EnergyMarch 2015 fixed$0.5890-29%
My Choice EnergyMarch 2016 fixed$0.5500-21%
Santanna Energy12 month fixed$0.6800-49%
Volunteer EnergyCallCallCall
XOOM Energymonth to month (promo)$0.4790-5%
XOOM Energy6 month fixed$0.6990-53%
XOOM Energy12 month fixed$0.6990-53%
XOOM Energy24 month fixed$0.6990-53%

SEMCO Energy – April 2014

SupplierPlanRate per ThermSavings
SEMCO Energymonth to month$0.4468N/A
Just Energy12 month fixed$0.6600-48%
Just Energy36 month fixed$0.6600-48%
Just Energy60 month fixed$0.6590-47%
Just Energy60 month variable$0.5630-26%
Lakeshore EnergyApril 2015 variableCallCall
My Choice Energymonth to monthCallCall
My Choice EnergyMarch 2015 fixed$0.5890-32%
My Choice EnergyMarch 2016 fixed$0.5650-26%
Volunteer Energymonth to monthCallCall

Consumers Energy Price History

DateRate per Mcf
4/2014$4.747
3/2014$4.710
2/2014$4.626
1/2014$4.626
12/2013$4.547
11/2013$4.586
10/2013$4.626
9/2013$4.583
8/2013$4.626
7/2013$4.710
6/2013$4.794
5/2013$4.766
4/2013$4.619
3/2013$5.450
2/2013$5.450
1/2013$5.450
12/2012$5.450
11/2012$5.450
10/2012$5.450
9/2012$5.450
8/2012$5.450
7/2012$5.450
6/2012$5.450
5/2012$5.450
4/2012$5.260
3/2012$6.101
2/2012$6.236
1/2012$6.145